ISO 31000: Risk Management Principles
Swanson Reed’s risk management framework, certified to the ISO 31000 standard, is founded on a set of principles that ensure risk is managed effectively throughout the entire organisation. These principles govern our conservative approach to Irish R&D tax advisory.
| Principle |
Description |
Implication for Irish R&D Tax Services |
| Integrated |
Risk management is not a separate activity; it is part of all organisational activities and processes, including decision-making. |
Risk considerations are built into the firm’s client engagement, scoping, and fee structure (e.g., avoiding contingency fees to minimise conflict of interest). |
| Structured & Comprehensive |
A systematic, timely, and organised approach to risk contributes to efficiency and consistent, comparable results. |
Ensures a standardised risk matrix is used for every Section 766 claim to consistently evaluate audit likelihood and potential risk severity. |
| Dynamic |
Risk management anticipates, detects, acknowledges, and responds to changes as risks emerge, change, and disappear. |
The firm continually monitors changes in Revenue Commissioners’ guidance and adjusts claim preparation methodologies immediately. |
| Best Available Information |
Inputs are based on historical and current data, explicitly considering limitations and uncertainties. |
Claims are substantiated with detailed, factual contemporaneous documentation (time logs, contracts, technical reports) to withstand audit scrutiny. |
| Continual Improvement |
Risk management is continually improved through learning and operational experience. |
Results from every internal review and Revenue compliance check are used to refine the Six-Eye Review process and documentation standards. |
Risk Management Process
While the principles are the foundation, the ISO 31000 process provides the practical steps that Swanson Reed follows to manage risks associated with client claims:
- Establish Context: Defining the firm’s objectives and the external/internal environment (e.g., the specific Irish tax jurisdiction and its audit risk).
- Risk Assessment:
- Risk Identification: Recognising potential tax compliance errors or Revenue audit triggers.
- Risk Analysis: Determining the likelihood and consequence (impact) of each risk.
- Risk Evaluation: Comparing the analysis results against the firm’s risk criteria (appetite).
- Risk Treatment: Selecting and implementing options to modify the risk (e.g., strengthening documentation, applying creditARMOR controls).
- Monitoring & Review: Continually checking the risk landscape and the effectiveness of internal controls.
- Communication & Consultation: Engaging key stakeholders (clients, auditors) throughout the process.
ISO 27001: Information Security Controls
ISO 27001 certification mandates the implementation of specific safeguards, or controls, organised into a framework to protect information. This is critical for handling confidential IP, financial models, and personal data under GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018.
The standard’s Annex A outlines the security controls grouped into four domains, demonstrating how Swanson Reed protects client data:
| Control Domain |
Focus Area |
Example Controls (Required of an ISO 27001 ISMS) |
| Organisational |
Information Security Governance and Policies |
Roles, Responsibilities, Segregation of Duties, Compliance with legal and statutory requirements. |
| People |
Security for personnel and human resource processes |
Screening, terms of employment, awareness training, non-disclosure agreements. |
| Physical |
Protecting physical premises and equipment |
Physical security perimeters, securing offices/rooms, protection against physical and environmental threats, clear desk policy. |
| Technological |
Utilising technology to protect data |
Secure authentication, privileged access control, data leakage prevention, encryption, malware protection, backup. |
The key takeaway is that ISO 27001 requires the firm to define its Information Security Management System (ISMS), ensuring security is continually assessed and improved.
Six-Eye Review | Compliant Irish R&D Tax Claim Preparation Process
Swanson Reed integrates its ISO-mandated risk mitigation directly into the workflow for preparing an R&D tax claim, primarily through a multi-step process culminating in our Six-Eye Review.
| Step |
Description |
Compliance & Risk Link |
| 1. Identification & Data Collation |
Identify qualifying R&D projects and collect contemporaneous technical and financial data (costs, time tracking, design documents). |
ISO 31000 (Risk Identification): Ensures all relevant data is collected upfront to support the claim’s eligibility and cost allocation. |
| 2. Technical Analysis & Write-up |
Qualified engineers/scientists draft the R&D report, detailing the scientific/technological uncertainty and the systematic process used to resolve it, as required under Section 766. |
Defensibility: Establishes the core technical argument proving the work meets statutory criteria for Qualified R&D. |
| 3. Financial Allocation & Computation |
Tax specialists apply detailed methodologies to allocate employee wages, subcontractor costs, and consumables to qualified R&D activities. |
Accuracy & Auditability: Ensures compliance with specific statutory tax regulations on eligible expenditure under Revenue guidelines. |
| 4. Mandatory Six-Eye Review |
The claim undergoes independent review by an Engineer, a Scientist, and a qualified Tax Consultant / Chartered Accountant. |
Compliance Quality Control: Minimises errors and maximises claim defensibility, aligning with ISO 31000 structured guidelines. |
| 5. Submission & Documentation |
The final, reviewed claim and all supporting documentation are submitted to the Revenue Commissioners. |
ISO 27001: All data handling, storage, and submission processes are secured by the ISMS to protect client confidentiality throughout filing. |
| Framework Element |
Description |
Implication for Clients |
| Six-Eye Review |
A mandatory internal review of every claim by a qualified engineer, a scientist, and a CTA / Chartered Accountant. |
Ensures the claim is technically sound, financially accurate, and compliant with Irish tax law, maximising defensibility. |
| ISO 31000:2009 (Risk Mgmt) |
An international certification for the firm’s comprehensive risk management policies and processes. |
Provides objective, third-party validation of the firm’s commitment to mitigating client tax risk. |
| ISO 27001 (Info Security) |
A leading global standard for establishing and maintaining an Information Security Management System (ISMS). |
Guarantees the highest level of protection for sensitive intellectual property and confidential financial data. |
| ISO 31000 Governance |
Systematic framework designed to systematically mitigate claim disallowance risks. |
Signifies a level of expertise and trustworthiness recognized across corporate governance networks. |
| Chartered Tax Expertise |
Led by qualified Irish tax advisers and chartered accounting professionals. |
Establishes the firm as an authority in Section 766 R&D claims, trusted across the industry. |